­Soviet ‘Easterns/Osterns’ of the 1920s: Adventure Films on the Caucasian Frontier of Russia
pdf (Русский)

Keywords

Caucasus Frontier Western Soviet Cinema Eastern People's Protector Ethno-Social Conflicts Masculine Culture Gender Attitudes

How to Cite

1. Dianova E. ­Soviet ‘Easterns/Osterns’ of the 1920s: Adventure Films on the Caucasian Frontier of Russia // Journal of Frontier Studies. 2024. № 3 (9). C. 200-225.

Abstract

The article elucidates the issue of representation in Soviet cinema of historical events that transpired during the formation of the Caucasian frontier and the interactions that emerged between the indigenous population and the tsarist troops. The term “Eastern” is analogous to the term “Western” which refers to films about the exploration of the Wild West. This is a useful way of conceptualizing Soviet silent films created on Caucasian material from the 19th–early 20th centuries. This article aims to examine feature films from the 1920s that depict Russia’s advance into the Caucasus. It seeks to identify similarities and differences between these films and the first Soviet “Easterns/Osterns” and “Westerns,” as well as to analyze the influence of ideological attitudes in historical science on the interpretation and depiction of events that took place on the Caucasian frontier. The visual sources utilized in this study include the silent films ‘Abrek Zaur’ (1926), ‘The Law of the Mountains’ (1927), and ‘Zelimkhan’ (1929). Additionally, published materials from the 1920s, including periodicals such as newspapers and magazines, were consulted. The study yielded insights into the stylistic similarities between classic Westerns and the first Soviet Easterns, including the portrayal of protagonists, the use of action and stunts, and the incorporation of jumps. The content of the films is correlated with real historical events, but they reflect the Bolshevik paradigm of history in the study of ethnosocial conflicts in the Caucasus. In films about highlanders, masculine culture is a dominant feature due to gender attitudes and the national cultural identity of the peoples of the Caucasus. Films about mountaineers were instrumental in shaping perceptions of the Caucasus during the early decades of the twentieth century. They illustrate the attributes of traditional culture, daily life, customs of mountain village inhabitants, the characteristics of the landscape, and architectural features. In general, films of an adventurous nature created on Caucasian material are of interest to those with an affinity for classic cinema, particularly the earliest Soviet Eastern films, as well as to researchers seeking to gain insight into significant historical and cultural information. This article is intended for those engaged in the study of the history of Soviet cinema.

https://doi.org/10.46539/jfs.v9i3.630
pdf (Русский)

References

“Abrek Zaur”: K postanovke. Stsenariy Izmaila Abay; Rezhisser B. Mikhin. Proizvodstvo Goskino. (1926). Kinopechat. (In Russian).

“Abrek Zaur”. (1926a). Sovetskoe Kino, 2, 30. (In Russian).

“Abrek Zaur”. (1926b, March 23). Kino. Ezhenedelnaya Gazeta. (In Russian).

“Pod vlastyu adata”. (1926, May 18). Kino. Ezhenedelnaya Gazeta. (In Russian).

“Robin Gud”. (1925, May 5). Kino. Ezhenedelnaya Gazeta. (In Russian).

“U pozornogo stolba”. (1924, May 20). Kino-Gazeta. (In Russian).

“Zakon gor”. (1928). Sovetskoe Kino, 1, 31. (In Russian).

“Zamechatelnaya strana eta Abrek-Zauriya!”. (1926, May 25). Kino. Ezhenedelnaya Gazeta. (In Russian).

Aksenov, V. P. (2004). Vesterny i isterny. Ogonek, 38, 49. (In Russian).

Basalaeva, I. P., Dubman, E. L., Khodarkovskiy, M., Milchev, V. I., Mizis, Yu. A., Sen, D. V., & Urushadze, A. T. (2020). How to study frontiers today? Discussion on the article by D. V. Sen’. Studia Slavica et Balcanica Petropolitana, 1, 81–105. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu19.2020.105 (In Russian).

Bestaeva, T. V. (2017). Bestaev Vladimir Gerasimovich. PeopleLife.Ru. https://peoplelife.ru/33618 (In Russian).

Bezrukova, A. A. (2010). About Some Aspects of Research of Gender Peculiarities of Traditional Northern Caucasus Peoples’ Culture. Vestnik Maykopskogo Gosudarstvennogo Tekhnologicheskogo Universiteta, 1, 32–34. (In Russian).

Confederat, O. V. (2019). Feature Film as Sum of Historical and Cultural Markers. To a Question of Visual Sources in Historical Sciences. Magistra Vitae: An Electronic Journal on Historical Sciences and Archeology, 1, 110–116. (In Russian).

Confederat, O. V. (2020). Vizualnyy istochnik kak kompleks istoriko-kulturnykh markerov. Informatsionnyy potentsial “telesnoy skhem” v igrovom filme. Dokumentalnoe Nasledie i Istoricheskaya Nauka: Materialy Uralskogo Istoriko-Arkhivnogo Foruma, Posvyashchennogo 50-Letiyu Istoriko-Arkhivnoy Spetsialnosti v Uralskom Universitete (Ekaterinburg, 11–12 Sentyabrya 2020 g.), 116–120. (In Russian).

Dadianova, T. V. (2013). “Osterny” zvezdy nemogo kino Vladimira Bestaeva. Kultura Rossii. Yaroslavskiy Portal. http://yarcult.org/faceshistory/bestaev/15714/ (In Russian).

Dashibalova, I. N. (2017). Problematistion of Ethnic Masculinity in a Visual Text (Based on the Example of the Film 'Bulag. The Sacred Spring'). Culture and Art, 5, 42–53. https://doi.org/10.7256/2454-0625.2017.5.19571 (In Russian).

Davydenko, V. (2014, April 1). Chem sovetskiy istern otlichaetsya ot klassicheskogo zapadnogo vesterna. Rossiyskaya Gazeta. https://rg.ru/2014/03/30/eastern-site.html?ysclid=lr4ox87tk4902134119 (In Russian).

Dvoretskiy, V. (1926). “Abrek Zaur”. Sovetskiy Ekran, 5, 4–6.

Egorov, S. O. (2022). Cinema, History, Ideology: Possible Approaches to the Film Text Interpretation. Historical Courier, 5, 11–20. https://doi.org/10.31518/2618-9100-2022-5-1 (In Russian).

Feldman, K. I. (1929). Pervye shagi “Vostokkino”. Sovetskiy Ekran, 19, 4–5. (In Russian).

Ferbenks v “Znake Zorro”. (1925, April 28). Kino. Ezhenedelnaya Gazeta. (In Russian).

Gatuev, D. (1981). Stakan sheykha: Sbornik. Ir. (In Russian).

Goryachok, K. L. (2020). Evolution of American Western Film: Vitality, Aesthetics, Mythology. Art & Culture Sudies, 2(33), 220–247. https://doi.org/10.24411/2226-0072-2020-00032 (In Russian).

Grashchenkova, I. N. (2014). Kinoantropologiya XX/20. Chelovek.

Gudaev, L. (2016). Film O. Frelikha “Zelimkhan” i Lado Bestaev. https://checheninfo.ru/81800-1929-g-film-ofreliha-zelimhan-i-lado-bestaev.html (In Russian).

Irkutov, A. D. (1927). “Abrek Zaur” (Beseda po kinolente). Kinopechat.

Istoriya natsionalnykh kinematografiy: Sovetskiy i postsovetskiy periody. (2020). Akademicheskiy proekt; Fond “Mir”.

Kartseva, E. N. (1976). Vestern. Evolyutsiya zhanra. Iskusstvo.

Khanakhu, R. A. (2001). Traditsionnaya kultura Severnogo Kavkaza: Vyzovy vremeni (sotsialno-filosofskiy analiz). Ayaks.

Lapina-Kratasyuk, E. G. (2011). Krasnoe na belom: K voprosu o kulturnoy spetsifike zhanra “istern”. Issues of Cultural Studies, 5, 117–120.

Lavrentev, S. A. (2009). Krasnyy vestern. Algoritm.

Magaramov, S. A. (2023). The Russian Frontier in the North Caucasus: Issues of Periodization. Journal of Frontier Studies, 8(4), 17–29. https://doi.org/10.46539/jfs.v8i4.514 (In Russian).

Maksimov, P. (1929). Moskva ne ponyala “Zelimkhana”. Revolyutsiya i Gorets, 10, 36–38. (In Russian).

Markelov, N. V. (2006). Pogovorim o burnykh dnyakh Kavkaza. Gelios ARV. (In Russian).

Matveev, V. A. (2016). Natsionalisticheskaya vandeya i proyavleniya ustoychivosti rossiyskoy integratsii na Severnom Kavkaze v krizisnykh usloviyakh 1917-1921 gg.: Soyuz kavkazskikh gornykh anarkhistov-terroristov. Ataman Zelimkhan. Kto on? Chto zastavilo vstat na put razboev?: Monografiya. Izdatelstvo Yuzhnogo federalnogo universiteta. (In Russian).

Neznamov, P. V. (1926, April 6). Kovboi v papakhakh. Kino. Ezhenedelnaya Gazeta. (In Russian).

Olkhovoy, B. S. (Ed.). (1929). Puti kino: Pervoe Vsesoyuznoe partiynoe soveshchanie po kinematografii. Teakinopechat. (In Russian).

Pervym ekranom na prosmotre. (1928, January 10). Kino. Ezhenedelnaya Gazeta. (In Russian).

Pobeda sovetskoy kinematografii. (1923). Kino. Dvukhnedelnik Obshchestva Kinodeyateley, 5(9), 13. (In Russian).

Razzakov, F. I. (2019). “Velikolepnaya semerka”, ili Vestern po-sovetski. https://litlife.club/books/114843/read?ysclid=lr4obe4n6h280802431&page=1 (In Russian).

Romanova, A. P., & Topchiev, M. S. (2014). The Caucasus as an Eternal Frontier. Caspian Region: politics, economy, culture, 3, 284–291. (In Russian).

Sapozhnikova, S. A. (1934). Zelimkhan: Borba kavkazskikh gortsev s ikh ugnetatelyami pri samoderzhavii: Metodicheskie ukazaniya k filmu. Izdatelstvo Upravleniya kinofikatsii pri SNK RSFSR. (In Russian).

Sovetskie khudozhestvennye filmy. Annotirovannyy katalog: V 3 tomakh: Vol. 1. Nemye filmy. (1918-1935). (1961). Iskusstvo. (In Russian).

Zakharov, D. V. (2023). Vestern. Bolshaya Rossiyskaya Entsiklopediya. https://bigenc.ru/c/vestern-54bda8?ysclid=lr91mz9kwg339526229 (In Russian).

Zorin, A. N. (2020). Westworld: From Evolution to Revolution of the Western. The Art and Science of Television, 16.3, 61–83. https://doi.org/10.30628/1994-9529-2020-16.3-61-85 (In Russian).

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.