The Belarusian Frontier of the 1920s: Did Belarusization Take Place in the Russian-Belarusian Border Area?
pdf (Русский)

Keywords

Soviet National Policy Indigenization Belarusization Russian-Belarusian Borderland Pskov, Smolensk, Bryansk Governorates

How to Cite

1. Kodin E. The Belarusian Frontier of the 1920s: Did Belarusization Take Place in the Russian-Belarusian Border Area? // Journal of Frontier Studies. 2024. № 3 (9). C. 175-199.

Abstract

The paper analyzes the historical circumstances of the 1920s, under which in three regions of the Russian-Belarusian borderland – Pskov, Smolensk and Bryansk governorates – it was necessary to reach the objectives of ‘Belarusization’: the size of the Belarusian population, the state of the school network in the NEP era and staffing for the solution of the “Belarusian question.” Belarusization is regarded as an integral part of the new Soviet national policy based on the resolutions of the 10th and 12th Congresses of the RCP.

The purpose of the study is to identify and characterize the basic conditions for carrying out Belarusization in Russian regions with compact residence of the Belarusian population. First, this concerns the size of the Belarusian population in these governorates at the beginning and during the process of Belarusization, and detection of the dynamics and reasons for its significant reduction, starting from the end of the 19th century. Secondly, special attention must be paid to the problems in the school education system during the NEP era (financial, material, personnel), the solution of which was of much higher priority for local authorities in comparison with the objectives of Belarusization.

The results of the study show that the policy of Belarusization in the Russian border regions failed to receive the due support either from local authorities overloaded with many other urgent tasks, or from the residents of the above mentioned governorates, including Belarusians. The practice of “self-Russification” became a kind of hidden form of protest among the Belarusian part of the population of the Russian border regions.

Conclusions: The policy of Belarusization in the Russian-Belarusian border regions was not carried out in full even in the “minor format” proposed by Moscow, largely due to its artificiality and implementation without taking into account the opinions of the majority of Russian Belarusians themselves. The study is intended for specialists in national and regional politics, and in Russian and Belarusian history.

https://doi.org/10.46539/jfs.v9i3.592
pdf (Русский)

References

Agricultural Statistics of Smolensk Province. (2011). Universum. (In Russian).

All-Union Population Census December 17, 1926: Brief Summaries. Issue 4: Nationality and Native Language of the USSR Population. (1928). USSR Central Statistical Administration. (In Russian).

Borisyonok, Y. A. (2008). The ‘Belarussianisation’ of the 1920s. Voprosy Istorii, 6, 133–136. (In Russian).

Borisyonok, Y. A. (2013a). On the Sharp Turns of Belarusian History: Society and State Between Poland and Russia in the First Half of the 20th Century. Rodina MEDIA LLC. (In Russian).

Borisyonok, Y. A. (2013b). The Polish Factor in National Policy of the Soviet Power in Belarus in the 1920th – the 1930th years. Modern and Contemporary History, 6, 55–65. (In Russian).

Borisyonok, Y. A. (2022). The Smolensk variant of Belarusianization in the 1920s. Slavic Almanac, 3–4, 463–478. https://doi.org/10.31168/2073-5731.2022.3-4.6.03 (In Russian).

Bryansk Province in Figures: A Brief Statistical Handbook on Bryansk Province. (1924). Red Book. (In Russian).

Center for Documentation of Recent History of Bryansk Region (CDRHBR). (n.d.-a). F. 1, In 1, C. 1597. (In Russian).

Center for Documentation of Recent History of Bryansk Region (CDRHBR). (n.d.-b). F. 1, In. 1, C. 1646. (In Russian).

Center for Documentation of Recent History of Bryansk Region (CDRHBR). (n.d.-c). F. 1, In. 1, C. 1910. (In Russian).

Data from the All-Russian Demographic Census August 28, 1920. Pskov Province. Issue 2. (Nationality, Gender, Literacy). (1923). (In Russian).

Dementyev, V. S. (2015). Settlement Patterns and Ethnic Composition of the Population of the Pskov Region in 1926-1939. Pskov Journal of Regional Studies, 24, 88–105. (In Russian).

Filimonov, A. V. (2016). Belarusians in Pskov Region (1920s). Scientific Notes of Vitebsk State University Named after P.M. Masherov: Collection of Scientific Works, 22, 45–55. (In Russian).

History of Bryansk Region. 20th Century. (2003). (In Russian).

Karsky, E. F. (1903). Belarusians: Vol. 1: Introduction to the Study of Language and Folk Literature. Warsaw Educational District Printing House. (In Russian).

Kobets, O. V. (2021). «Sentenced to Belarusization»: Smolensk Belarusians in the 1920s (to the Question of Their Number). Izvestia of Smolensk State University, 1, 199–217. https://doi.org/10.35785/2072-9464-2021-53-1-199-217 (In Russian).

Kodin, E. V., & Kobets, O. V. (2019a). Belarusization in the Russian-Belarusian Borderland: Smolensk Region, 1924-1929. Belarusian Thought, 8, 85–91. (In Russian).

Kodin, E. V., & Kobets, O. V. (2019b). Smolensk Region, 1921-1925: Belarusization from Above? Izvestia of Smolensk State University, 2, 164–177. (In Russian).

Kodin, E. V., & Kobets, O. V. (2021). Belarusization in Smolensk Region, 1920s. Smolensk State University Publishing House. (In Russian).

Manakov, A. G. (2013). Russian-Belarusian Borderland: Historical-Geographical Determination. Pskov Journal of Regional Studies, 16, 169–176. (In Russian).

Markova, M. T. (2004). Essays on the History of Public Education in Pskov Province. 1900–1927. Pskov State Pedagogical Institute named after S.M. Kirov. (In Russian).

Nekrylova, O. G. (2021). The Experience of Creating Contract Schools During the Construction of the Soviet School System in the 1920s. Problems of Social and Humanitarian Sciences, 2, 82–86. (In Russian).

Ostrovsky, Z. (1931). Problems of Ukrainization and Belarusization in the RSFSR. Power to the Soviets. (In Russian).

Population of Bryansk Province According to the 1926 Census. (1927). Bryansk Provincial Statistical Department. (In Russian).

Population of the Empire According to the January 28, 1897 Census. By Districts. (1897). Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. (In Russian).

Practical Resolution of the National Question in the Belarusian Socialist Soviet Republic. Part I: Belarusization. Based on Materials from the Central National Commission of the CEC of the BSSR. (1927). Central National Commission of the CEC of the BSSR. (In Russian).

Preliminary Results of the All-Union Population Census of 1926 for Pskov Province. (1927). Pskov Provincial Statistical Department. (In Russian).

Public Education in Pskov Province According to Preliminary Results of the 1921 Survey of Public Education Institutions (April 1). (1921). First State Printing House. (In Russian).

Rabochiy Put. (1922, December 10). (In Russian).

Rabochiy Put. (1924, December 18). (In Russian).

Rabochiy Put. (1926, January 13). (In Russian).

Rabochiy Put. (1927, November 2). (In Russian).

State Archive of Bryansk Region (SABR). (n.d.-a). F. 84, In. 1, C. 542. (In Russian).

State Archive of Bryansk Region (SABR). (n.d.-b). F. 84, In. 1, C. 1126 (Part 1). (In Russian).

State Archive of Smolensk Region (SABR). (n.d.-a). F. R-19, In. 1, C. 3093. (In Russian).

State Archive of Smolensk Region (SABR). (n.d.-b). F. R-19, In. 1, C. 3903. (In Russian).

State Archive of Smolensk Region (SABR). (n.d.-c). F. R-19, In. 1, C. 4745. (In Russian).

State Archive of Smolensk Region (SABR). (n.d.-d). F. R-19, In. 1, C. 4746. (In Russian).

State Archive of Smolensk Region (SABR). (n.d.-e). F. R-19, In. 1, C. 4748. (In Russian).

Tenth Congress of the RCP(b). March 1921. Stenographic Report. (1963). State Publishing House of Political Literature. (In Russian).

The First General Census of the Population of the Russian Empire, 1897. XXXIV. Pskov Province. Notebook 2. (1904). Publication of the Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. (In Russian).

Yalozina, E. A. (2015). Payment for Education in Soviet Schools in the 1920s. Manuscript, 12(3), 218–221. (In Russian).

Zhuravskaya, A. V. (2022). Provincial Teaching. 1920s. (Based on Materials from Bryansk and Smolensk Provinces). History. Society. Politics, 2, 49–54. (In Russian).

Zolotaryov, O. V. (2009). Soviet Teaching in the 1920s. Intelligentsia and the World, 3, 28–40. (In Russian).

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.