“Own Foreign Land”: The Transformation of Attitudes Towards the Pre-War Past of the Region in the “Kaliningradskiy Komsomolets” Newspaper During the Perestroika Period
pdf (Русский)

Keywords

Perestroika Kaliningrad Region Press Content Analysis The Own The Other Places of Memory Appropriation Historical Memory

How to Cite

1. Saenko A. “Own Foreign Land”: The Transformation of Attitudes Towards the Pre-War Past of the Region in the “Kaliningradskiy Komsomolets” Newspaper During the Perestroika Period // Journal of Frontier Studies. 2024. № 1 (9). C. 60-81.

Abstract

The perestroika-time public discussion about the “white spots” of history in the Kaliningrad region focused on the history of East Prussia, which had previously been under a tacit ban. This article analyzes publications about the pre-war past of the region in the popular youth newspaper “Kaliningradskiy komsomolets” from 1985-1991. It examines the process of changing the regional historical narrative and characterizes the transformation of the historical memory of Kaliningrad residents during the years of perestroika. The paper aims to trace how the “discovery” of East Prussian themes occurred, who promoted the new historical narrative and by what means, and the stages through which the process of “appropriation” of the cultural heritage inherited after the war by the inhabitants of the region went. The study utilized a qualitative-quantitative content analysis method of newspaper texts, conducted with the help of the MAX QDA 2020 program. The results were interpreted using the categories of “Our Own” and “the Other” from B. Wandelfels’ philosophical concept and P. Nora’s “place of memory” one. The paper concludes that by the early 1990s, Kaliningrad society had varied approaches to the “pre-Soviet” period ranging from denial of the significance of the “foreign” and “the Other” heritage to its full acceptance as “one’s own”. The analysis of the content of the publications, including the commemorative practices reflected in the newspaper, shows that the regional historical narrative changed during the years of perestroika. The course of “exorcising the Prussian spirit”, approved immediately after the war, although not completely eradicated, became a marginal phenomenon, while the study, preservation, and utilization of the experience and historical and cultural heritage of the predecessors became the dominant trend in which the press of the glasnost’ era played a significant role.

https://doi.org/10.46539/jfs.v9i1.545
pdf (Русский)

References

Artyushenko, V. (1988, March 26). Zdravstvuy, «Komsomolets»! Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Baranova, E. V., Davidenko, A. A., Dement'ev, I. O., Kostyashov, Yu. V., Kretinin, G. V., Mankevich, D. V., Maslov, V. N., Megem, M. E., Filev, M. V., & Shepel', Ya. G. (2022). “Sovetskiy narod” na kraynem zapade Rossii 1945—1991): Teoriya i praktika formirovaniya «novoy istoricheskoy obshchnosti v Kaliningradskoy oblasti. Izdatel'stvo BFU im. I. Kanta. (In Russian).

Belintseva, I. V. (2020). Arkhitektura Vostochnoy Prussii: Fakty i interpretatsii. Zhivem. (In Russian).

Brovkov, A. A. (1988, January 30). S pometkoy “Zvezdochet”. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Dementyev, I. O. (2015). A ‘divided history’: the politics of memory on the territory of the former East Prussia in the light of current discussions. Baltijskij region, 4, 105–120. https://doi.org/10.5922/2074-9848-2015-4-6 (In Russian).

Dorogavtseva, I. S. (2006). Problema Drugogo v zapadnoy kul'ture [PhD Thesis]. Chita. (In Russian).

Erokhina, O. V., & Zakharov, V. Yu. (2023). «“The Other/Own/Alien”: Paradoxes of Perception of Germans in the Russian Empire in the late 18th – early 20th centuries. Journal of Frontier Studies, 8(1), 32–46. https://doi.org/10.46539/jfs.v8i1.494 (In Russian).

Galtsov, V. I. (2017). Reflections on the History of the Kaliningrad Region. Slovo.ru: baltijskij accent, 8, 7–17. https://doi.org/10.5922/2225-5346-2017-2-1 (In Russian).

Ganin, V. (1988, April 16). Stroki iz pisem. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Garskova, I. M. (2018). Istoricheskaya informatika. Evolyutsiya mezhdistsiplinarnogo napravleniya. Aleteyya. (In Russian).

Gordeev, I. (1988, July 9). S chego nachinaetsya Rodina. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Gubin, A. (1990, November 17). Kenigsbergskaya letopis'. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Illarionov, I. (1988, July 9). Istoriya. Kul'tura. Sovremennost'. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Ivanov, Yu. (1987, January 25). Sunduk Kanta. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Ivanov, Yu. (1988, January 16). My mnogoe mozhem. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Khrappa, V. (1988, April 23). My – narod. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Klimentov, V. (1988, July 9). Prochital “otkrytoe pis'mo”. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Kostyashov, Yu. V. (2003). Izgnanie prusskogo dukha: Kak formirovalos' istoricheskoe soznanie naseleniya Kaliningradskoy oblasti v poslevoennye gody. Kaliningradskiy gosudarstvennyy universitet. (In Russian).

Kostyashov, Yu. V. (2017). Vospriyatie i memorializatsiya kul'turnogo proshlogo Kenigsberga v sovremennom Kaliningrade. In Modernizatsiya kul'tury: Ot cheloveka traditsii k kreativnomu sub"ektu (Vol. 1, pp. 237–241). Samarskiy gosudarstvennyy institut kul'tury. (In Russian).

Kretinin, G. V. (2015). Ob istokakh formirovaniya istoricheskoy pamyati zhiteley Kaliningradskoy oblasti (1945-1960). IKBFU's Vestnik. Series: Humanities and social science, 12, 61–66. (In Russian).

Krutik, A. (1988, January 30). Ideyu podderzhivayu. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Mikhaylov, M., & Sotnikov, D. (1988, March 26). Strannaya tendentsiya. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Nikolaeva, Zh. V. (2021). The Identity Feature: the Emergence of the City. Journal of Frontier Studies, 6(1), 144–159. https://doi.org/10.46539/jfs.v6i1.258 (In Russian).

Nora, P., Ozuf, M., Pyuimezh, Zh., & Vinok, M. (1999). Frantsiya-pamyat'. Izdatel'stvo SPbGU. (In Russian).

Pavlov, Yu. (1988, March 26). Pozitsiya ne ustraivaet. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Pavlova, A. (1988, April 16). Stroki iz pisem. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Rozhkov, K. (1988, April 16). Chto pod silu turistu? Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Sedov V. (1989, August 5). Mertvyy ostrov, ili sensatsii moglo ne sostoyat'sya. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Shub, M. L. (2016). Sovremennye kommemorativnye praktiki. Chelyabinskiy gumanitariy, 36(3), 80–87. (In Russian).

Shukurov, R. M. (1999). Chuzhoe: Opyty preodoleniya. Ocherki iz istorii kul'tury Sredizemnomor'ya. Aleteya. (In Russian).

Sogrin, V. V. (1992). Perestroyka: Itogi i uroki. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost', 1, 133–147. (In Russian).

Steblov, K. (1988, January 30). Ideyu sozdaniya fonda podderzhivayu. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Vlasova D. (1989, April 8). Kenigsbergskiy detektiv. Kaliningradskiy komsomolets. (In Russian).

Waldenfels, B. (1995). Svoya kul'tura i chuzhaya kul'tura. Paradoks nauki o “chuzhom”. Logos, 6, 77–94. (In Russian).

Yakushenkov, S. N., & Yakushenkova, O. S. (2016). “Power of land”: formation of new otherness in the conditions of frontier. Journal of Frontier Studies, 1, 9–21. (In Russian).

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.